“Something will have gone out of us as a people if we ever let the remaining wilderness be destroyed ... We simply need that wild country available to us, even if we never do more than drive to its edge and look in.” ― Wallace Stegner
I have to say, when I am being honest with myself, that even considering all that has happened this year, and in the recent past, I may be happier and more content with my life than I could ever have imagined I would be.
Out on the ranch.
Looking at the positive, I have five healthy, lively, bright children, including my newest baby girl, a gift to me this year. My mother is with me and a great help in so many ways. My aunts have come to help me and they do every day. My uncle is also a great help. All those working for me are solid people, diligent, good-natured and as glad as I am to be able to work and thrive in God's own country.
Where can I sit?
Which brings me to the ranch, so beautiful, so serene, so life-giving. Besides my children and my people, my life revolves around animals. Of course, the cow-chans and horsies, chickens and ducks, but tumbled in among the kidsters are our dogs and cats, both indoor and outdoor varieties, that add so much to life. I'm typing this now with a cat on my chest while my mini-me sits at the piano practicing Ma mère l'Oye. My two bigger boys are studying on the floor by the fireplace. My mother is rocking the baby and my toddler has fallen asleep on the couch with his head resting on a dozing dog. It's a moment of tranquility after a typical madly busy day.
Then there is the life all around, the Americana, if you will, the traditional holidays and local festivals, the county fair, Civil War and Indian War re-enactments, the rodeos. So many things to look forward to and participate in. My kids are crazy about all of it and I make sure they never miss anything, even if I can't go.
Rodeo queens
Although popular culture always depicts church as boring and tiresome, we all enjoy doing things involving "faith-based" (what does that even mean; who invented that stupid phrase?) activities. Choral singing is a joy, especially considering the themes the songs teach. And that's just one thing.
Thanksgiving is coming up and we are all deep into preparations for a huge family feast. We are also preparing a special meal at the cookhouse for all the ranch workers and their families. We are going to make it a day off as much as possible and will have fun contests and games. A sharpshooting contest is traditional, the old turkey shoot, a horseshoe contest, a roping contest and all sorts of such things. Friday will also be a day off, again as much as ranch work allows. Animal care has no days off.
A sculpture of me my husband made.
To be honest, and to permit myself a sense of loss that I try to block out of my mind, I do miss Jeff very much. Not hearing his voice at church, not listening to him read bedtime stories to the kids, not being able to ask him for advice, gosh not even posing for him for his projects, photography, carving, sculpting. I was his forever model. So much of my day-to-day life revolved around him and now that is all gone. It's funny, you know: he was a big tough guy, gruff and commanding, and yet he could be so tender to me and the children and with our pets. His loss was devastating to them -- yes even the dogs and cats! -- in ways I haven't been able to write about. I started a post about how my oldest boy reacted, but I have had to put it aside. I couldn't...just couldn't.
Okay, Wanda, that about enough of that. You started this post to celebrate the positive and look what you are doing. Quit it.
Well, it's a beautiful day. I'll go take a little walk and clear my head. Then get on with getting on.
I’ve used Chat GPT to sharpen and improve photos and people have claimed they are AI-generated images even though they are not. I asked Google’s AI to explain why this happens, using the below photo of me, showing it the original photo and the enhanced photo, and I think its explanation is worth knowing:
“The photo was flagged as AI-created because ChatGPT does not simply apply a traditional sharpening filter; instead, its image model completely regenerates the entire picture from scratch to produce the higher-resolution version.
When you ask ChatGPT to enhance, upscale, or sharpen an image, the system treats your upload as a visual reference and generates a brand-new file. Because of this process, two things happen:
Full Pixel Regeneration. Unlike traditional photo editors that modify existing pixels, generative AI models reconstruct every texture, hair strand, fabric weave, and logo based on your original photo. Looking closely at the two versions, you can see that the individual strands of hair, the knit pattern on the socks, and the stylized "W" on the mug were entirely redrawn rather than just sharpened.
Automatic C2PA Tagging. Because OpenAI's image generation system creates a brand-new output file, it automatically embeds C2PA Content Credentials into the metadata. These credentials label the output file's origin as a new AI creation from OpenAI, without distinguishing between an image made from a text prompt and one regenerated from an uploaded photo.”
Here's the original photo:
And here's the photo enhanced by ChatGPT:
I think what ChatGPT did makes the image better (although the hair color is not quite right; it usually isn't in photos). But if people are going to say rude things about it, well, phooey.
By the way, if you can see similarities in the clothes and hair in my photo here with that in my animated dance videos, well, yeah, lol. I use myself for the motion-capture model and in my animations I wear the sorts of things that I wear IRL. Those are not made with AI, by the way, but Blender, a very old software program.
Believe it or not, I read the following fairly obscure and erudite joke in a science fiction story by Murray Leinster (neeWilliam Fitzgerald Jenkins), "Sam, This is You," first published in the May, 1955, edition of Galaxy:
A telephone
lineman's girlfriend, urging him to aspire to better things, asks him:
"Do you want to spend your life with your arms wrapped around a pole?"
And he replies, "Well, it was good enough for George Sand."
You don't get it? Well, see, the composer Frédéric
Chopin was Polish and George Sand, who was a girl not a boy, was a
19th century French novelist with whom he had an intense affair. The artist Eugène
Delacroix even painted a portrait of them together. Neither Leinster
nor his editor, H.L. Gold, thought the joke would fly above the heads of
the magazine's audience, primarily young men, including lots of high
school and even junior high school students. Alas, could the same be
said today?
I tell this story because I'm back on the theme of the death of western civilization and my belief that it's already gone. We're in some kind of civilizational interregnum in which trailing wisps of the past still linger in intellectual valleys over which the gloom of ignorance advances every day and on high peaks of culture no one even looks up at any more, let alone climbs.
In my previous post I mentioned The Great Guildersleeve, a family situation comedy spun off from Fibber McGee and Molly, the most popular radio show in the country for 10 years according to the Hooper pole. It was immediately popular when it premiered in 1941. It was sponsored by Kraft Foods, which used the show to promote Parkay margarine and its new product, Kraft Macaroni and Cheese -- "cooks in seven minutes!" The adventures of buffoonish Uncle Guildy and his starry-eyed niece Margery and school-hating nephew Leroy centered around life in the small town of Summerfield.
In one episode, broadcast in 1942, Leroy is complaining because he has to memorize a chunk of Longfellow's narrative poem Hiawathaand recite it in front of the class. Guildersleeve chides him, reminding him that the other students in his class also have to memorize parts of the poem and recite it so that the whole poem will be recited by the class. Then he says that he had to memorize the poem when he was in school and can still remember it. He begins intoning "This is the forest primeval. The murmuring pines and the hemlocks, bearded with moss, and in garments green...."
Guildy, Margery and Leroy.
Margery interrupts him and sarcastically says, "That's Evangeline!" as the live audience laughs loudly. The audience got the joke and when the script was written everyone involved with the show knew the radio audience would get the joke, too, because everybody in those days had to read those poems in school and memorize parts of them. They had to learn other poems as well. It was part of being socialized as an American, so everyone could recite The Village Blacksmith, The Snow Storm and The Old Oaken Bucket, to name just a few.
But today? What kid is required to memorize any poem, let alone one as demanding as Evangeline or Hiawatha? What kid has even heard of them? What teacher, for that matter?
In a 1943 broadcast of the Jack Benny Show, a comedy-variety program sponsored by Post Grape Nuts Flakes cereal, one of the commercials for the cereal was made up of the names of four operas: Faust, Aida, Tannhäuser and Lohengrin. The audience laughed at the the bit. Again, neither the writer, sponsor or anyone else associated with the show thought such a commercial would fly over the heads of the audience because everybody knew those operas, familiar old standards that lots of people could pick out a tune from on the piano or sing.
But today? How many people have even heard of these operas -- or any opera -- and would "get" the commercial? It would make no sense to them. Certainly no ad agency would approve of such a commercial.
What was the commercial? "The Faust thing tomorrow morning have a bowl of sweet, tasty Grape Nuts Flakes for breakfast. I Aida them every day. Whether you live in a red house, a white house or a Tannhouser, you'll love America's most popular cereal. So even if you are feeling Loengren you will grin with Grape Nuts Flakes." Yeah, it's pretty lame. Even Jack Benny snarked that Loengren got dragged into it kicking and biting. But still.... Ya know? The audience didn't sit on their hands, exchange baffled glances, go "Huh?" But today? I doubt if the writers of commercials are familiar with those operas, let alone any audience.
When did the decline start? When did we begin abandoning our civilization? I was talking about this with my mother and she remembers when she was in high school in the mid-1960s in English class when it came time to learn how to parse sentences her teacher said that she was supposed to teach that but that she considered it boring and a waste of time so they would skip it.
When my mother mentioned this to her mother, my grandmother, she said that they had been taught to parse sentences in grammar school. That's why it was called grammar school. Did she complain to the school about this lapse? My mother said she didn't recall her doing so, but she did sit her down and teach her how to parse sentences, explaining why she needed to know this. As when it came time, my mother explained it to me.
I recall reading an article from an old Saturday Evening Post issue from, if memory serves, 1950 or thereabouts. The Post was, I think, at the time the oldest continuously published magazine in the United States, dating back to the 18th century, founded by Benjamin Franklin. Anyway, this article was complaining about the decline in competency of school teachers, noting that until recently they had been trained in what were called Normal schools, with a curriculum especially designed to produced highly skilled and knowledgeable educational professionals. But in recent years, grade school teachers had been recruited from the ranks of former telephone operators who had very little training in educating children.
The author pointed to two causes for this: first, the then-new baby boom, which overwhelmed the educational system with a flood of children the numbers of which it was not equipped to handle; and second, the loss of jobs by traditional telephone switchboard operators whose jobs had been replaced by automatic switching equipment. These women found work as school teachers to fill the demand unmet by Normal school graduate numbers. The author of the article implied these former telephone operators were dumber than Normal school graduates and weren't up to the task of teaching.
Again, I asked my mother about this. She recalled that in kindergarten and first grade she had attended school in what were former army barracks, then in old multi-story schools with creaking floors and small windows, but her high school was brand new, a sprawling one-story affair with lots of windows, gym, auditorium, swimming pool, audio-visual room and so on. Her freshman class was its very first. She did remember most of her early grade-school teachers were young women, but by the time she was in fifth grade they were older grumpy men who held their students' feet to the fire. Then when she went to high school it was back to young women, with only one grumpy old man that she remembered as a tough, no-nonsense instructor. She'd never thought about that before.
So maybe the baby-boom generation, through no fault of their own other than being born in vast numbers, caused the decline of our civilization. Standards declined because there were not enough people to maintain them. I don't know. Just a thought. Obviously, there were other reasons as well. Contemporary social critics like Vance Packard cited television as a major cause of declining intellectual vigor. But if you look at the kinds of TV programs available in the 1950s and early 1960s, what was considered low-brow then would make PBS hang its head in shame. Omnibus, US Steel Hour, The Bell Telephone Hour, The Tonight Show with Jack Paar, and on and on.
But, of course, there was a lot of dumb stuff blasted out into the culture, mostly then as now, stories about crime and, above all, murder. That's got to have an effect on the culture. But I think that began with radio. We tend to forget about radio, but what a socially transforming invention that was. We are so used to mass media that we forget that it was really radio that created it. You can track its influence by comparing radio sales with piano sales. In 1910 there was one piano for every 252 Americans. Piano sales peaked in 1924 and then went into a slide they've never recovered from. Sales of pianos dropped off in step with the increase in sales of radios. Sales of sheet music followed a similar path.
So before radio (and the phonograph), if you wanted to hear music you and your friends played and sang it yourself. You had to learn to read sheet music and how to play a musical instrument. You learned to sing at least reasonably well, probably in church, where the moral values of your culture were inculcated in you.
Well, I'm digressing down a rabbit hole of probable causes. You could write a book about this. Maybe I will. I've got about half of it done already, scattered in varies notes, posts and articles.
So, what's the big deal about culture? Why does it matter to the ordinary person overwhelmed by just making it through this vale of tears?
Well, remember when I wrote about the once legendary early 19th century poem "Casabianca" by Felicia Hemans? About a boy calling out to his father, asking him what he should do under dire circumstances, not knowing that his father is dead. Then I wrote about Louis Simpson's poem "Carentan O Carentan." That was about a battle Simpson, serving with the 101st airborne, was in during World War Two in which his unit was all but wiped out. In the poem he calls on his captain, then his lieutenant, then his sergeant to tell him what to do. But they are all dead and he gets no answer, just as the boy who stood on the burning deck of his ship called out to his dead father asking what he should do and got no answer.
Wasn't there a connection echoing down the generations linking Simpson, pinned down under fire at Normandy on D-Day 1944, with the 10-year-old Giocante Casabianca aboard the French warship L'Orient during the Battle of the Nile in 1798? Telling him this has happened before, what you are experiencing is not new or unique. Others have faced it before, and responded with courage, duty, sacrifice. Now it's your turn. You can be as brave as that child and face what you have to face.
Isn't that worth something? Something important to you as an individual? You are part of a continuing story. Simpson must have thought so because he echoed in his poem the question of of a century and a half previous. Simpson learned that poem in school, had to memorize and recite it. He probably thought doing so was boring. Some dumb poem. But it stuck with him and came to him in his moment of trial.
Now think about a soldier today. Does he have that same comfort, if we can call what the poem gave "comfort"? No. He has nothing. He is alone in himself. Cut off from the generations of his civilization. He knows not Casabianca nor Carentan. And isn't that a terrible thing? To not be enfolded in a world?
I think so. And I am bereft at is loss.
Well, I'll put a sock in it now. I could write more. Believe me, I could. But I've got work to do.
“Happiness is not a possession to be prized, it is a quality of thought, a state of mind. Of course we have our moments of depression; but there are other moments too, when time, unmeasured by the clock, runs on into eternity.” ― Daphne du Maurier, Rebecca
I've been doing the old FML here a bit lately and I need to cut it out. Yeah, it's been a tough year, to say the least. Yeah, I'm a bit overwhelmed. But I am making progress. Some things I thought I never could deal with I have dealt with. Some things I thought I could never manage, I am managing.
“Don't wish me happiness. I don't expect to be happy all the time... Wish me courage and strength and a sense of humor. I will need them all.” ― Anne Morrow Lindbergh
Won the Nobel Prize. I should be like her.
Sailors and cowboys know how to use rope and tie knots.
I have to admit I am rather proud of myself for coping so well, getting a handle on things, learning so many things, overcoming so many challenges. And I really am beginning to see daylight after so much darkness.
And there are days when I realize just how lucky -- yes, lucky -- I am. There are probably millions of people who would love to live the life I am living. Maybe even envy it. So I shouldn't complain about it. I really shouldn't.
********
Another day at the office.
When the weather is mild, I sleep with my windows open and the only sound I hear is the occasional night bird and the wind, if there is any. Often it's just a light breeze that rustles the leaves of the trees. I hear frogs peeping in season. Crickets. Very often coyotes at any time of year. Last night they woke me up they were so loud and close. But usually they are off in the distance somewhere.
Of course I hear cattle lowing. Now if you are not familiar with cattle you may think lowing is, well, low. But it's not. It ranges from grunting to bellowing. It can be startlingly loud.
During the day, it is often so quiet that if you are sitting outside and a leaf falls, it sounds like a terrific crash and for a second you wonder what in the world was that and then you realize, oh, it was just a leaf. I bet you don't believe that if you live in the city or anywhere the noise of humans dominates the environment. But it's true. Otherwise the sounds of birds are the most common, especially in the morning and evening. You can hear the caws of crows and ravens any time of day, as you can the "crees" of hawks, the scolding jays and in season other birds, robins and whatnot. The rapping of woodpeckers can be quite loud. Once in a while you can hear the rasping croak of a heron rowing across the sky.
When I take a walk the loudest sounds are my footfalls and my breathing. Once in a while I'll be startled by the thrashing of a deer leaping up out of a thicket and bounding away from my path. I always apologize for disturbing them, calling out, "Don't worry, it's all right. It's just me." They've gotten used to the sound of my voice so they slow down, sometimes stop and look back, then pretend to graze on a bit of grass while keeping an eye on me as I pass by.
Otherwise the wind is the noise-maker. It's often very strong, and I mean very strong. Hold on to your hat or it's gone for good. I do enjoy the sound of the wind rustling leaves. We have a eucalyptus tree that must be a good 30 or maybe 40 feet tall the leaves of which rustle in the slightest whisper of wind. It can be odd to be out near it and there is not a sound, not a leaf stirring and then suddenly its leaves begin murmuring and flickering in the light, stirred by the tiniest breath of air.
********
I've mentioned Plato and Socrates and even Callicles a few times on this blog in musings about how I think about life. To me, it's just a normal sort of thing to do, just the same as I have quoted Sidney Hook, Herman Melville, Thrasymachus, Justin Martyr, Marcus Aurelius, Shakespeare or a verse or two from the Bible. But I have noticed on-line pontificators trashing Plato and Socrates and I've wondered why. They don't attack them for particular things, just in general, no specifics. All they do is mention their names and bad-mouth them.
Their dismissal made no sense to me. Then I realized that those people have only heard their names, never read, let alone pondered, thought about, what they say. I think these people feel intimidated by them, more specifically by their own lack of knowledge of them, their shallow education. Because these same people will invoke Lord Voldemort, a character from a children's book, in their philosophical meanderings. That's the height and depth of their intellectual world. It's pathetic.
I don't say that in some condescending, sneering way. Far from it. I say it in dismay and disappointment. It's a sign of just how far we have fallen as a civilization in such a very short time. For example, a 1956 story arc of the radio series Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar, a 15-minute five-part weekly serial based on the cases of an insurance investigator, involved Callicles. The solution to the mystery centered on Callicles' view of natural justice. In fact, the episode cycle was called "The Callicles Matter."
Think of that. A popular, mass-appeal whodunit broadcast by CBS revolved around a classical Greek philosopher mentioned in the dialogues of Plato and nobody, not the writer, the producer, the broadcaster, the advertisers, thought a thing about it. No one thought the audience would not understand the show or think it high-falutin' snooty pants blather. The mass audience of mid-20th century America was expected to be familiar with Greek philosophy. Seventy-five years later, not so much. In fact, not at all. Harry Potter is as deep as it gets. What's the point of trying to have a serious discussion of physis versus nomos or anything else with these clods? They are too damned ignorant and stupid (forgive my French, but I am annoyed) to even realized how ignorant and stupid they are, how banal and trite their thoughts are. Western civilization is not dying. It's dead.
You think I'm exagerating? I wish! Back in the early 1940s in one episode of the hugely popular radio family comedy The Great Guildersleeve, Guildersleeve's friendship with Judge Hooker is described as like that between Damon and Pythias. How many would get that reference today? Would you? In 1942, everyone got it. And isn't our culture poorer because their story is forgotten?
Oh, well, Ima put away my Qualitative Quantitative Ontological Lapsometer now It ain't doin' me no good. (Y'all git th' reference? Uh huh. Well, I know you do. But them other guys....)
As dear old Albert Camus once pondered, shall I commit suicide or have a cup of coffee?
Coffee it is!
(Okay, okay, he didn't really say that. I know. It's just a Reader's Digest condensed version of La mort heureuse. I'll shut up now.)
********
“I believe there is a theory that men and women emerge finer and stronger after suffering, and that to advance in this world we must endure ordeal by fire. This we have done in full measure. We have both known fear, and loneliness, and very great distress. I suppose sooner or later in the life of everyone comes a moment of trial.” ― Daphne du Maurier, Rebecca
Things I've learned since I have become the head honcho of this outfit:
(By the way, did you know that honcho comes from the Japanese word hanchō (班長), meaning section or unit chief, especially in the military. US occupation troops in Japan and during the Korean War picked it up, changing the pronunciation to honcho and adding "head" for those with more authority.)
Okay, enough of that. I could go on, you know. Want me to tell you about "skosh"?
Where was I?
Oh, right. Um...
So like, remember when I wrote about shooting a mountain lion that time when it killed my dog and my panicked horse bucked me off when I fired and I caught a hoof on the way down? And the horse ran away. And I, pretty badly injured, carried my dog back home, walking quite a few miles from the remote line shack near where the incident occurred. Yeah. Fun times.
Well, what I didn't know then was that, by law, I was required to leave my dog at the scene, not move him or the lion, cover both their bodies and surrounding tracks with a tarp and notify Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks within 72 hours of the incident. They would send a game warden out to inspect the scene and decide whether or not the killing was justified, then take away the carcass of the lion to do a necropsy.
Well the second, it took me almost two days, hobbling along with a stick as a crutch, to get home -- with my dog. I was not going to leave him! He died protecting me. Then the priority for my family was to get me to a hospital, not comply with all that crap. But now I know why my dad flew the Aviat Husky out to the scene and checked it out. That was a dangerous thing to do in winter, as it was, and land where there was no airstrip. And take off. Very few pilots would even contemplate doing that. But my dad was totally the best. There was nothing he couldn't make an airplane do.
He did that to comply as much as possible with the damned government requirements. Oh, and a game warden did come out to the ranch and chastise my dad for me having moved my dog, but he was too chicken to fly out to the site and finally accepted the photos my dad took of the scene and his examination of my dog's body as well as my injuries as proof the shooting was justified. He did still want the carcass and said he would be back to get it, and come spring he did, but by then it was gone, of course, dragged away and eaten by other predators and carrion eaters.
I never knew anything about those events or those rules.
Anyway, fast forward to earlier this year and what else I learned. Some of our cattle got into larkspur, which is a beautiful flowering plant but deadly to cattle, killing them within hours of eating it. We keep cattle out of pastures with larkspur till after it has gone to seed, but this year, maybe due to the weather, some larkspur bloomed late or something. Anyway, cattle got into it and died. That was bad enough. But their carcasses attracted predators and scavengers, most especially grizzly bears. The grizzlies attacked and killed more of our cattle.
Now, you'd think we could just go up there and shoot the damn bears. That's what I thought. Oh, no. No, no, no.
You can only legally kill a grizzly bear if it is in the act of killing livestock. Now how the hell often are you going to be out on the range with your cattle when that happens? I mean really. Come on.
But that's the law.
I am going to paste an AI summary of all the crap you have to go through to deal with a predator killing your livestock. It is just too much, man. Just too much. But you have to do it. And you know what? Just about everything involving ranching is regulated by federal, state and local laws, ordinances, advisories.... So much for the wild west. This is the land of the bureaucrat and the cowed. Huh. That's a pun. Sort of. "The cowed." Get it? I made a funny. Ha. Ha.
And I have to get guard llamas. I shitteth thee not. Guard llamas! What in the world? God is just fucking with me for the lulz. (Okay, the Government, not God. Same diff.)
Oh, we can still shoot the gol' durn coyotes on sight. But in California I hear you can't even do that. Probably soon enough we won't be able to do that either.
There's more official crap to deal with. Want me to tell you what all we have to do to get reimbursed for the animals killed by predators? Sit yourself down for a spell, friend.... But this is enough to give you an idea of what a rancher has to deal with to get you your quarter-pounder.
Anyway, now you know why I am so tired these days. I have so much to deal with. Why not hand it off to the ranch manager? Because I have to know about it all, understand what needs to be done, how things operate. I can't just be some flibbertigibbet trusting to the good will of the world.
I also don't want to be the kind of boss who, when you have a problem, says why not do so-and-so and you explain exactly why you can't do that and he just stares blankly at you and when you are finished says, well, I don't see why you can't and you want to swear at him and say I just told you why we can't but you say, yes, good idea, we'll look into that and get back to you. I don't want to be that boss. I want to know at least as much as those doing the work do and, if possible, even more, so I can be of some value to them or at least not be an impediment.
So I have a ranch to run, employees to deal with, five children to raise, an ailing mother, a...; well, a lot is on my plate. I know. Boo hoo.
But on top of this, people are urging me to date. Move on with my life and all that. Ride down, rope and hog-tie a new husband. Put him in harness and set him to work: Tote that barge, lift that bale, load 16 tons. They don't put it that way, but that's what they're saying. They don't understand that even if I wanted to, were I to go on a date with Mr. Wonderful, say to some romantic Italian restaurant, as he was charming me with his charisma, composing love poetry to me on the spot, I would doze off and splat face-first into my spaghetti, my snores bubbling the sauce.
Forget it.
________________
The AI summary:
When past livestock kills or persistent predator threats occur in Montana, ranchers cannot handle the situation privately. Instead, they must trigger an official state and federal intervention protocol. Because grizzly bears are federally protected, and wolves/mountain lions are strictly managed by the state, the details of trapping, removal, and official kill permits are highly regulated:
1. The Investigation (The First Step)
Before any trapping or permit is issued, an official investigation must confirm the predator threat: • Who to call: The rancher must immediately contact USDA Wildlife Services or Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks (FWP). • Evidence preservation: The rancher is required to protect the carcass and the site from scavengers (often covering tracks or using tarps) so investigators can look for specific predatory signs (e.g., specific bite marks or tracks). • The Verdict: An official agent must formally classify the incident as a "confirmed" or "probable" predator depredation.
2. Trapping and Relocation / Removal
If a chronic conflict is confirmed, government specialists (not the rancher) take control of the trapping and removal process: • Who does it: Only authorized federal USDA Wildlife Services agents or state FWP biologists are legally permitted to set traps or snares for these large predators. • Relocation: If the bear or wolf has no prior history of livestock conflicts and is caught in a flexible management zone, authorities may choose to drug, tag, and relocate the animal to an approved wilderness area. • Lethal Removal: If the animal is deemed a repeat offender, highly habituated to livestock, or a threat to human safety, government agents will euthanize the animal.
3. Official Kill Permits (Issued to the Rancher)
Under Montana Code Annotated § 87-5-301, the Director of Montana FWP can issue a conditional, non-transferable kill permit directly to a livestock owner (or their authorized employee) to shoot a specific problem animal: • The "Threatening" Threshold: The permit is only issued if FWP legally determines that a specific animal poses a persistent threat to humans or livestock. • The Nonlethal Prerequisite: Montana administrative rules require ranchers to demonstrate and document that they have first attempted nonlethal deterrence measures (such as electric fencing, carcass removal, guard dogs, or fladry) before a kill permit will be granted, particularly if the livestock are grazing on public lands. • Strict Geography: The permit is strictly limited to the specific boundaries where the owner's livestock are legally authorized to graze. It does not give the rancher permission to hunt or track the animal outside their property or active public allotment. • Reporting Deadlines: If a rancher successfully takes an animal under an official kill permit, they must report the kill to FWP within 24 hours (compared to the 72-hour window allowed when catching an animal "in the act") and surrender the carcass.
Under Montana Administrative Rules (ARM 12.9.1304), "nonlethal effort" is legally defined as a variety of active husbandry practices and physical deterrents meant to mitigate wildlife conflicts without killing the predator. To show valid proof when applying for an official kill permit, a rancher must demonstrate they have deployed specific, documented tools from the following categories:
1. Physical and Visual Deterrents
• Fladry or Turbo-Fladry: Highly visible flags hung from fencing lines to deter wolves. Turbo-fladry incorporates an electric shock wire running through the flags. • Electric Fencing: Temporary or permanent high-tensile electric fencing designed to keep large carnivores away from calving pastures or night pens. • Scare Devices: Deployment of motion-activated alarms, strobe lights (such as Foxlights), or noise-making devices like starter pistols and cracker shells.
2. Guarding and Husbandry Practices
• Range Riders: Hiring or acting as a range rider to maintain an active, daily human presence around grazing livestock to deter predators. • Livestock Guarding Animals: Active deployment of specially trained livestock guard dogs (such as Anatolian Shepherds or Akbash), guard llamas, or donkeys. • Shed Lambing or Calving: Confining vulnerable pregnant or newborn livestock into secure indoor sheds, night pens, or smaller, highly managed structures.
3. Attractant Management
• Carcass Removal: Rapidly cleaning up and removing dead livestock from the pasture to ensure predators are not being actively baited or drawn to the herd. • Grazing Management: Altering pasture rotations, utilizing supplemental feed to keep cattle bunched tightly together, or moving vulnerable stock to alternative, lower-risk pastures during peak predator activity.
How to Prove It to State Officials
The state requires an incremental approach before issuing a lethal permit. Ranchers prove their nonlethal compliance through: • Written Ranch Management Plans: Documenting active grazing rotations, carcass disposal strategies, and predator deterrence protocols. • Visual Evidence: Providing time-stamped photographs or video proof of electric fencing, fladry installations, and guard animals actively working the herd. • Logbooks and Receipts: Keeping meticulous daily logs of human presence (range rider schedules) and receipts for purchased deterrence equipment. • Joint Monitoring: Participating with Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks (FWP) or USDA Wildlife Services to track radio-collared predators in the area, proving that deterrents were actively deployed in the direct vicinity of known packs.
Reading Plato's Republic, in Book VI I came across this:
"Those who...have...seen enough of the madness of
the multitude know that no politician is honest, nor is there any champion of
justice at whose side they may fight. They may be compared
to a man who has fallen among wild beasts -- he will not join in the wickedness
of his fellows, but neither is he able singly to resist all their fierce
natures, and therefore seeing that he would be of no use to the state or
to his friends, and reflecting that he would throw away his life
without doing any good either to himself or others, he holds his peace
and goes his own way. He is like one who, in the storm of dust and sleet
which the driving wind hurries along, retires under the shelter of a wall;
and seeing the rest of mankind full of wickedness, he is content if only
he can live his own life."
I agree with that sentiment and hope to convey it to my children so that they do not throw their lives away on some political crusade or trumped up war, revolution or riot. Stay out of the way of the thundering herd and keep your own council. Think what you will but express little of what you think or, better yet, nothing at all.
Jean-Pierre Claris de Florian, the 18th century French poet, was of a similar mind. He is most remembered today for averring that, as it is usually phrased in English, "to live well, live hidden"; that is, out of the way of events. Alas, it did him no good, for he was deemed an enemy of the Revolution and imprisoned, only spared from the guillotine by Robespierre's death, instead, still imprisoned, dying of tuberculosis in 1794.
The fable in which the famous line is the moral:
LE GRILLON
Un pauvre petit grillon Caché dans l’herbe fleurie Regardoit un papillon Voltigeant dans la prairie L’insecte ailé brilloit des plus vives couleurs L’azur, le pourpre & l’or éclatoient sur ses ailes. Jeune, beau, petit-maître, il court de fleur en fleur, Prenant & quittant les plus belles. Ah ! disoit le grillon, que son sort & le mien Sont différents ! dame Nature Pour lui fit tout, & pour moi rien. Je n’ai point de talent, encor moins de figure ; Nul ne prend garde à moi, l’on m’ignore ici bas ! Autant voudroit n’exister pas. Comme il parloit, dans la prairie Arrive une troupe d’enfants. Aussitôt les voilà courans Après le papillon dont ils ont tous envie : Chapeau, mouchoirs bonnets, servent à l’attraper. L’insecte cherche vainement à leur échapper, Il devient bientôt leur conquête. L’un le saisit par l’aile, un autre par le corps ; Un troisième survient, & le prend par la tête : Il ne falloit pas tant d’efforts Pour déchirer la pauvre bête. Oh ! oh ! dit le grillon, je ne suis pas fâché ; Il en coûte trop cher pour briller dans le monde. Combien je vais aimer ma retraite profonde ! Pour vivre heureux, vivons cachés.
*************************************************
I've been reading Plato's Socratic dialogue Gorgias, and became intrigued by the ideas of Callicles, aka Mr. Realpolitik. Appropriate reading for these times. Aside from his brutally frank evaluation of democracy and non-idealistic views on how society should be organized, Callicles also has something to say worth considering in his advocacy of hedonism: Maybe that really is all we should concern ourselves with. Maybe the "if it feels good, do it!" hippy-dippy Sixties pop philosophy is correct. At least for those of us with no power and no influence, living lives without significance or consequence, except to our small circle of friends and family; people who also are much as we are: observers on the sidelines, who, for all the good it does, might as well not even bother observing, but just ignore it all and get on with their own lives.
My father always described the events of the larger world as "a dull background roar" that it's not worth paying attention to. Of course, that dull background roar had a lot of influence on his life, mine as well, as I suppose it does us all.
But...if you could really do just what you wanted to do, would it really involve politics, law, foreign policy and all that stuff, or would you want to shine work on, pig out on all of your favorite foods and drinks, have all the sex you wanted...just let your id run wild. It sounds attractive. I remember reading a book called Memoirs of a Round-Heeled Woman or something like that. It was written by a person who decided at the age of 67 that she was going to have as much sex as possible from then on, and, by golly, she did! I was kind of grossed out by the idea of a grandma...you know...but, man, she went for it and had the time of her life, after having lived the routine marry, have children, raise them, work hard, behave yourself existence of us normies.
I think when I get to be that age all I'll want to do is knit and take naps, but who knows? Maybe the thing to do is indulge yourself while your animal appetites are still strong and your body can handle them. The problem, of course, is that you could hurt important people in your life by being a self-centered pleasure seeker. You could lose a lot more than you could ever gain. And you might very well end up being a jaded, diseased, friendless wreck.
So I guess the thing to do is to indulge with your partner. I suppose that's why there are clubs, bars, dance venues and fancy restaurants -- all places where you and your significant other can indulge your appetites together. Alas, I'm too much of a germophobe to do very much indulging. I'll just hold your beer.
So, anyway -- here's to hedonism, such as it is. Eat, drink and be merry, and let the rest of the world go by.
By the way, in case you can't read it, the overlay text in the image above reads:
"Callicles argues that the 'best life' entails the indulgence of one's appetites. The good life doesn't consist of restraining one's desires, but in knowing how to indulge them. The individual who would live correctly ought to allow his own appetites to get as large as possible and not restrain them."
It's from the dialogue where Callicles debates natural justice and pleasure with Socrates. Socrates has a different point of view, to put it mildly. This is the dialogue where Socrates introduces the allegory of the leaky jars, which is kind of okay, I guess, but ol' Soc goes on from there to really mop the floor with Calli-chan. Ima make sure my kids read this dialogue and we talk about it from every angle. If you ain't not done readed it, y'all should. Def should.
Yeah, I reckon. Kinda. I guess. I am a big fan of tranquility.
If all y'all wanna take this yhar test, here she be.
This song is more me, actually.
Friday, October 30, 2026
“Joy, sorrow, tears, lamentation, laughter -- to all these music gives voice, but in such a way that we are transported from the world of unrest to a world of peace, and see reality in a new way, as if we were sitting by a mountain lake and contemplating hills and woods and clouds in the tranquil and fathomless water.” ― Albert Schweitzer
My daughter seeks out the piano to work out the grief of losing her father. She plays slowly and thoughtfully.
The first movement of Copland's Violin Concerto arranged for solo piano.