Sunday, June 26, 2022

Better the devil you know?

We chatted outside on the porch after dinner about how things would change if there was a nuclear war and Washington, D.C. and the state capital got destroyed. Would we even know it was my first thought, but then others chimed in with more practical opinions:
No more taxes!
No more expensive and nonsensical requirements and regulations!  If we wanted to open a business, we could just do it.  We could hire whomever we wanted.  Families would have to stick together to take care of the aged and ill, educate and protect children, defend against intruders.
We could enforce our own rights!  (Not sure what that meant, but I think it would be like if you caught a rustler -- yes, they exist! -- you could handle him the way they did 150 years ago, and with no delay).
Then there were more thoughtful considerations:

Would paper money still have value, or would we have to barter or transact with specie?  If a gang of thieves and murderers arose to pillage the countryside, how would we deal with it?  (That one was easy:  we'd form posses or militias and hunt them down and exterminate them.)  But what if an army of raiders swept over the land, like Comanches, Vikings or Huns?  We'd have to build walls and forts, let no strangers who might be spies come near.
And so on. No one thought it would be a disaster.  But some women did worry about life in a lawless world.  The men dismissed that fear.  It was more important that finally we could be left alone to live our lives without being pestered and plagued by politicians and bureaucrats.    I said but the raiders who would prefer to pillage than work would be professional warriors, skilled in warfare and weaponry, violent and cruel.  How could we herdsmen and farmers successfully fend them off?  We'd have to develop our own warrior caste, who would inevitably rule over us, extracting tribute, taxes if you will.  So we'd be back where we started, only without the benefits of an advanced civilization.  No one had an answer to that and the subject was changed.