Monday, November 16, 2026

Decline, decline

 Believe it or not, I read the following fairly obscure and erudite joke in a science fiction story by Murray Leinster (nee William Fitzgerald Jenkins), "Sam, This is You," first published in the May, 1955, edition of Galaxy:   

A telephone lineman's girlfriend, urging him to aspire to better things, asks him: "Do you want to spend your life with your arms wrapped around a pole?" And he replies, "Well, it was good enough for George Sand." 

You don't get it?  Well, see, the composer Frédéric Chopin was Polish and George Sand, who was a girl not a boy, was a 19th century French novelist with whom he had an intense affair.  The artist Eugène Delacroix even painted a portrait of them together.  Neither Leinster nor his editor, H.L. Gold, thought the joke would fly above the heads of the magazine's audience, primarily young men, including lots of high school and even junior high school students.  Alas, could the same be said today?  

I tell this story because I'm back on the theme of the death of western civilization and my belief that it's already gone.  We're in some kind of civilizational interregnum in which trailing wisps of the past still linger in intellectual valleys over which the gloom of ignorance advances every day and on high peaks of culture no one even looks up at any more, let alone climbs.

In my previous post I mentioned The Great Guildersleeve, a family situation comedy spun off from Fibber McGee and Molly, the most popular radio show in the country for 10 years according to the Hooper pole. It was immediately popular when it premiered in 1941. It was sponsored by Kraft Foods, which used the show to promote Parkay margarine and its new product, Kraft Macaroni and Cheese -- "cooks in seven minutes!"  The adventures of buffoonish Uncle Guildy and his starry-eyed niece Margery and school-hating nephew Leroy centered around life in the small town of Summerfield.  

In one episode, broadcast in 1942, Leroy is complaining because he has to memorize a chunk of Longfellow's narrative poem Hiawatha and recite it in front of the class.  Guildersleeve chides him, reminding him that the other students in his class also have to memorize parts of the poem and recite it so that the whole poem will be recited by the class.  Then he says that he had to memorize the poem when he was in school and can still remember it.  He begins intoning "This is the forest primeval. The murmuring pines and the hemlocks, bearded with moss, and in garments green...."

Guildy, Margery and Leroy.

Margery interrupts him and sarcastically says, "That's Evangeline!" as the live audience laughs loudly.   The audience got the joke and when the script was written everyone involved with the show knew the radio audience would get the joke, too, because everybody in those days had to read those poems in school and memorize parts of them.  They had to learn other poems as well. It was part of being socialized as an American, so everyone could recite The Village Blacksmith, The Snow Storm and The Old Oaken Bucket, to name just a few.

But today?  What kid is required to memorize any poem, let alone one as demanding as Evangeline or Hiawatha? What kid has even heard of them?  What teacher, for that matter?

 In a 1943 broadcast of the Jack Benny Show, a comedy-variety program sponsored by Post Grape Nuts Flakes cereal, one of the commercials for the cereal was made up  of the names of four operas:  Faust, Aida, Tannhäuser and Lohengrin. The audience laughed at the the bit.  Again, neither the writer, sponsor or anyone else associated with the show thought such a commercial would fly over the heads of the audience because everybody knew those operas, familiar old standards that lots of people could pick out a tune from on the piano or sing.

But today?  How many people have even heard of these operas  -- or any opera -- and would "get" the  commercial?  It would make no sense to them.  Certainly no ad agency would approve of such a commercial.

What was the commercial?  "The Faust thing tomorrow morning have a bowl of sweet, tasty Grape Nuts Flakes for breakfast. I  Aida them every day. Whether you live in a red house, a white house or a Tannhouser, you'll love America's most popular cereal. So even if you are feeling Loengren you will grin with Grape Nuts Flakes." Yeah, it's pretty lame.  Even Jack Benny snarked that Loengren got dragged into it kicking and biting.  But still.... Ya know? The audience didn't sit on their hands, exchange baffled glances, go "Huh?" But today? I doubt if the writers of commercials are familiar with those operas, let alone any audience.

When did the decline start? When did we begin abandoning our civilization?  I was talking about this with my mother and she remembers when she was in high school in the mid-1960s in English class when it came time to learn how to parse sentences her teacher said that she was supposed to teach that but that she considered it boring and a waste of time so they would skip it.

When my mother mentioned this to her mother, my grandmother, she said that they had been taught to parse sentences in grammar school.  That's why it was called grammar school.  Did she complain to the school about this lapse? My mother said she didn't recall her doing so, but she did sit her down and teach her how to parse sentences, explaining why she needed to know this. As when it came time, my mother explained it to me.

I recall reading an article from an old Saturday Evening Post issue from, if memory serves, 1950 or thereabouts. The Post was, I think, at the time the oldest continuously published magazine in the United States, dating back to the 18th century, founded by Benjamin Franklin.  Anyway, this article was complaining about the decline in competency of school teachers, noting that until recently they had been trained in what were called Normal schools, with a curriculum especially designed to produced highly skilled and knowledgeable educational professionals. But in recent years, grade school teachers had been recruited from the ranks of former telephone operators who had very little training in educating children.

The author pointed to two causes for this: first, the then-new baby boom, which overwhelmed the educational system with a flood of children the numbers of which it was not equipped to handle; and second, the loss of jobs by traditional telephone switchboard operators whose jobs had been replaced by automatic switching equipment. These women found work as school teachers to fill the demand unmet by Normal school graduate numbers. The author of the article implied these former telephone were dumber than Normal school graduates and weren't up to the task of teaching.

Again, I asked my mother about this.  She recalled that in kindergarten and first grade she had attended school in what were former army barracks, then in old multi-story schools with creaking floors and small windows, but her high school was brand new, a sprawling one-story affair with lots of windows, gym, auditorium, swimming pool, audio-visual room and so on. Her freshman class was its very first. She did remember most of her early grade-school teachers were young women, but by the time she was in fifth grade they were older grumpy men who held their students' feet to the fire.  Then when she went to high school it was back to young women, with only one grumpy old man that she remembered as a tough, no-nonsense instructor.  She'd never thought about that before.

So maybe the baby-boom generation, through no fault of their own other than being born in vast numbers, caused the decline of our civilization. Standards declined because there were not enough people to maintain them.  I don't know. Just a thought. Obviously, there were other reasons as well. Contemporary social critics like Vance Packard cited television as a major cause of declining intellectual vigor.  But if you look at the kinds of TV programs available in the 1950s and early 1960s, what was considered low-brow then would make PBS hang its head in shame.  Omnibus, US Steel Hour, The Bell Telephone Hour, The Tonight Show with Jack Paar, and on and on.

But, of course, there was a lot of dumb stuff blasted out into the culture, mostly then as now, stories about crime and, above all, murder.  That's got to have an effect on the culture. But I think that began with radio. We tend to forget about radio, but what a socially transforming invention that was.  We are so used to mass media that we forget that it was really radio that created it.  You can track its influence by comparing radio sales with piano sales.  In 1910 there was one piano for every 252 Americans. Piano sales peaked in 1924 and then went into a slide they've never recovered from.  Sales of pianos dropped off in step with the increase in sales of radios. Sales of sheet music followed a similar path.

So before radio (and the phonograph), if you wanted to hear music you and your friends played and sang it yourself.  You had to learn to read sheet music and how to play a musical instrument.  You learned to sing at least reasonably well, probably in church, where the moral values of your culture were inculcated in you.

Well, I'm digressing down a rabbit hole of probably causes.  You could write a book about this.  Maybe I will. I've got about half of it done already, scattered in varies notes, posts and articles.

So, what's the big deal about culture? Why does it matter to the ordinary person overwhelmed by just making it through this vale of tears? 

Well, remember when I wrote about the once legendary early 19th century poem "Casabianca" by Felicia Hemans? About a boy calling out to his father, asking him what he should do under dire circumstances, not knowing that his father is dead. Then I wrote about Louis Simpson's poem"Carentan O Carentan." That was about a battle Simpson, serving with the 101st airborne, was in during World War Two in which his unit was all but wiped out. In the poem he calls on his captain, then his lieutenant, then his sergeant to tell him what to do.  But they are all dead and he gets no answer, just as the boy who stood on the burning deck of his ship called out to his dead father asking what he should do and got no answer. 

Wasn't there a connection echoing down the generations linking Simpson, pinned down under fire at Normandy on D-Day 1944, with the 10-year-old Giocante Casabianca aboard the French warship L'Orient during the Battle of the Nile in 1798? Telling him this has happened before, what you are experiencing is not new or unique. Others have faced it before, and responded with courage, duty, sacrifice. Now it's your turn. You can be as brave as that child and face what you have to face.

Isn't that worth something? Something important to you as an individual? You are part of a continuing story. Simpson must have thought so because he echoed in his poem the question of of a century and a half previous. Simpson learned that poem in school, had to memorize and recite it. He probably thought doing so was boring.  Some dumb poem.  But it stuck with him and came to him in his moment of trial.  

Now think about a soldier today.  Does he have that same comfort, if we can call what the poem gave "comfort"? No.  He has nothing.  He is alone in himself. Cut off from the generations of his civilization. He knows not Casabianca nor Carentan.  And isn't that a terrible thing? To not be enfolded in a world?

I think so. And I am bereft at is loss.

Well, I'll put a sock in it now. I could write more.  Believe me, I could. But  I've got work to do.


The Bell Telephone Hour 

Casabianca

  The boy stood on the burning deck,
Whence all but he had fled;
The flame that lit the battle's wreck,
Shone round him o'er the dead.

Yet beautiful and bright he stood,
As born to rule the storm;
A creature of heroic blood,
A proud, though childlike form.

The flames rolled on -- he would not go,
Without his father's word;
That father, faint in death below,
His voice no longer heard.

He called aloud -- 'Say, father, say
If yet my task is done?'
He knew not that the chieftain lay
Unconscious of his son.

'Speak, father!' once again he cried,
'If I may yet be gone!'
-- And but the booming shots replied,
And fast the flames rolled on.

Upon his brow he felt their breath
And in his waving hair;
And look’d from that lone post of death,
In still yet brave despair.

And shouted but once more aloud,
'My father! must I stay?'
While o'er him fast, through sail and shroud,
The wreathing fires made way.

They wrapped the ship in splendour wild,
They caught the flag on high,
And streamed above the gallant child,
Like banners in the sky.

There came a burst of thunder sound --
The boy -- oh! where was he?
Ask of the winds that far around
With fragments strewed the sea!

With mast, and helm, and pennon fair,
That well had borne their part,
But the noblest thing which perished there,
Was that young faithful heart.

 

Carentan O Carentan 

Trees in the old days used to stand
And shape a shady lane
Where lovers wandered hand in hand
Who came from Carentan.

This was the shining green canal
Where we came two by two
Walking at combat-interval.
Such trees we never knew.

The day was early June, the ground
Was soft and bright with dew.
Far away the guns did sound,
But here the sky was blue.

The sky was blue, but there a smoke
Hung still above the sea
Where the ships together spoke
To towns we could not see.

Could you have seen us through a glass
You would have said a walk
Of farmers out to turn the grass,
Each with his own hay-fork.

The watchers in their leopard suits
Waited till it was time,
And aimed between the belt and boot
And let the barrel climb.

I must lie down at once, there is
A hammer at my knee.
And call it death or cowardice,
Don’t count again on me.

Everything’s all right, Mother,
Everyone gets the same
At one time or another.
It’s all in the game.

I never strolled, nor ever shall,
Down such a leafy lane.
I never drank in a canal,
Nor ever shall again.

There is a whistling in the leaves
And it is not the wind,
The twigs are falling from the knives
That cut men to the ground.

Tell me, Master-Sergeant,
The way to turn and shoot.
But the Sergeant’s silent
That taught me how to do it.

O Captain, show us quickly
Our place upon the map.
But the Captain’s sickly
And taking a long nap.

Lieutenant, what’s my duty,
My place in the platoon?
He too’s a sleeping beauty,
Charmed by that strange tune.

Carentan O Carentan
Before we met with you
We never yet had lost a man
Or known what death could do.